


Report by John Patrick Heeley
It had to end sooner of later and it took a bad day at the office combined with the gritty determination of a Plymouth side to put a stop to Wigan Athletic's unbeaten start to the league campaign.
Without taking anything away from Bobby Williamson's side, they deservedly won this competition hands down, Wigan quite simply looked all over the place and the overall performance was a shadow of those that we have had the pleasure to witness so far this season.
OK so Ellington was missing after failing a late fitness test due to the knock he picked up at Stoke and the loss of McCulloch with less than thirty minutes on the clock would obviously have had some impact but if Wigan have any aspirations of Premier League football next season then this should not be used as an excuse.
Plymouth came looking for the win, something that many sides visiting the JJB Stadium do not, content on sitting back with numbers at the back hoping for Wigan to make a mistake, all credit to the West Country side.
Wigan started the game reasonably well however and Jason Roberts threatened the Plymouth goal three times in the early exchanges but for once his killer instinct was missing.
His first opportunity was presented to him by midfielder Alan Mahon who sent him clear on goal with a clever through ball but the Grenada international pulled his effort inches wide of the upright with only a few minutes on the clock.
Roberts was denied minutes later after doing all the hard work by taking the ball round French keeper Romain Larrieu but his goal bound shot was cleared away by defender Peter Gilbert.
Mahon tried his luck with a powerful shot from distance after 21 minutes but lifted his attempt over the bar as Wigan went for the goal that they hoped would kill off their opponents.
McCulloch limped from the field just before the half hour mark and was rushed straight to Euxton Hall Hospital for treatment to an ankle injury with Steve McMillan replacing him but his former team mate at Motherwell clearly out of match practice and was himself substituted later in the game.
Roberts then saw himself with just the keeper between him and goal in the 35th minute but as he bore down on David Graham's forward ball Larrieu bravely dove at his feet to collect and snuff out the danger.
However five minutes later Plymouth took the lead after not really threatening Filan as such but from then on in it was the visitors that ran the show.
The goal came from a free kick after Steve McMillan had brought down Lee Makel 25 yards out. David Friio tapped the resulting kick to skipper PAUL WOTTON who rattled it towards the wall but just as it looked as if it was ending up against the advertising hoardings Leighton Baines stuck out a leg and deflected the ball past Filan.
Plymouth were almost two goals to the better just before the break but Keith Lasley's acrobatic kick cracked the post with the Aussie keeper beat.
The second half saw Wigan at sixes and sevens with little to show for their endeavours but with just over 25 minutes remaining they still had something to play for but a rare mistake in the Wigan defence gifted Plymouth a second goal.
Ian Breckin, normally Mr. Dependable, cut out a David Norris ball but a lapse in concentration saw him send a pass back to Filan unaware that substitute STEVIE CRAWFORD was waiting to pounce and the Scottish international took himself round Filan before sending the ball home from an acute angle.
Crawford was in a perfect position to double his tally with just over 10 minutes left on the clock after Mahon had lost the ball to Friio on the half way line and sent the former Dunfermline striker clear but his shot sailed wide of the near post with Filan covering and somehow, and the reasoning was well beyond me sat behind that goal, the linesman (some 40 yards away) adjudged that the Wigan keeper had got a touch to it and awarded a corner just as the goal kick was about to be taken.
Latics did have one last shake of the dice just before referee Phil Prosser blew time on proceedings but Leighton Baines directed his header straight into the keeper's arms but it would have been too little, too late to save them from their first league defeat of the season.
Wigan now have a week to pick themselves up as they prepare for the trip to the capital for the tough challenge of Queens Park Rangers.
WIGAN ATHLETIC
PLYMOUTH ARGYLEVenue: JJB Stadium
Attendance: 10,294
Kick Off: 15:00
Referee: Phil Prosser, Gloucestershire